Skip to main content

Are the Giants the Worst Team in the NFL?


After years of underachieving, the New York Giants went 11-5 in 2016, losing to the Green Bay Packers in the Wildcard round. With head coach Ben McAdoo entering his second season, the addition of wide receiver Brandon Marshall, and the core of the playoff team intact, the Giants were expected to make another run for the playoffs this year, maybe even the Super Bowl.

Defensive end Jason Pierre-Paul has been quoted, now infamously, for saying he didn't see a reason why the Giants wouldn't go 16-0.

Fast forward to October. The Giants are 0-4 and alone at the bottom of the NFC East. Forget the NFC East, they are tied for the NFL's worst record and are more likely to win a top draft pick than a playoff spot.

Week One was a tough loss to the Dallas Cowboys, as the Giants fell 19-3 and couldn't sustain any offense without Odell Beckham. Week Two featured an embarrassing loss, as there are many ways the Giants could have managed to defeat the Detroit Lions on that Monday night.

Since then, the Giants have been a slightly different team against the Philadelphia Eagles and Tampa Bay Buccaneers. They've shown signs of life, the offense has been scoring in the 20's, and the players haven't given up just yet.

It still hasn't translated to any wins.

Following back-to-back game winning field goals by the Eagle and Buccaneers, the Giants went 0-2 in these road games despite averaging 23.5 points per game. The defense can be blamed, specifically the lack of wrapping up on tackles leading to huge plays.

So the question at hand: are the New York Giants the worst team in the NFL?


Four teams are currently winless in the 2017 season: The Los Angeles Chargers, Cleveland Browns, San Francisco 49ers, and the Giants. 

While Browns rookie DeShone Kizer has shown flashes of quality play, you'd be hard-pressed to argue the Browns are more talented than the Giants in any major area. The Giants would likely be favored in any matchup with Cleveland.

The 49ers are another team that just doesn't a roster with enough raw talent to make any wins easy. Brian Hoyer was great in a Thursday night loss to the L.A. Rams. San Francisco put up 39 points in that game. In their other three games? 3, 9, and 15 points. Their offense would have an especially hard time matching up with Landon Collins and the Giants stellar secondary.

The last team left is the hardest to peg: the L.A. Chargers. For over a year, the Chargers have been losing painfully close games. This year has been no different, as three of their four losses have been decided by three points or less.

Luckily, we'll get an answer to which 0-4 is better very soon: the Giants host the Chargers on Sunday in MetLife Stadium.

L.A. is easily more talented than San Francisco or Cleveland. In many ways, the Chargers and Giants are in similar situations. Both teams have much more talent than the other two winless teams this season.

Are the Giants in a bad spot considering their expectations? Yes, of course. All the effort that went in to building this year's roster is all but lost unless the Giants can rattle off a long win streak.

But are the Giants the worst team in the NFL? Despite mishaps and misfortunes for Big Blue this year, the worst team in the NFL is either the Cleveland Browns or San Francisco 49ers.  

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Patriots Quickly Lose Underdog Status in Fluctuating Vegas Line

Championship Sunday gave us two wild overtime games with the winners set to meet in two weeks at Super Bowl 53 in Atlanta. On Sunday night, the Los Angeles Rams opened as slight one point favorites, which would have had Tom Brady and the New England Patriots play the underdog role once again. The line quickly shifted to a pick 'em game. This feels like the most accurate reflection of the game's odds. While the Rams finished with a better regular season schedule, Brady and the Patriots are playing in their third straight Super Bowl and it would be tough to call them true underdogs. As Monday progressed, bettors started shifting the line in favor of the Patriots, likely to reflect early bets. Many bettors probably saw taking an underdog Patriots team as an easy bet. The line could go even deeper in New England's favor, or perhaps balance out closer to a pick 'em. Realistically, the line won't favor either team by more than 1 or 2 points, making it essentia...

NFL Divisional Round Reactions

The second round of the NFL playoffs told a different tale than Wildcard Weekend. After home teams went 1-3 in the playoffs opening weekend, they won, often in impressive fashion, going 4-0 in the Divisional Round. Four home teams, four favorites, four high-scoring offenses. The Kansas City Chiefs, New England Patriots, Los Angeles Rams, and New Orleans Saints all held 6-2, 7-1, or 8-0 home records in the regular season, and they carried the home-field advantage into the playoffs. In my personal picks, I went 3-1, incorrectly predicting the LA Rams would slip up and allow the Dallas Cowboys to advance. The most exciting and close game was between the Eagles and Saints, with New Orleans winning by a score and Nick Foles nearly pulling off a game-winning drive. My Playoff Week 2 Picks #Chiefs over #Colts ✅ #Cowboys over #Rams ❌ #Patriots over #Chargers ✅ #Saints over #Eagles ✅ Last week’s record: 3-1 Playoff record: 6-2 — Sak Sports Blog (@SakSports) January 14, ...

Carmelo Anthony Traded to Chicago Bulls, Will Be Released

Veteran Carmelo Anthony, who appeared in a mere 10 games for the Houston Rockets and none since November 8, has been traded from the Houston Rockets to the Chicago Bulls for cash considerations. According to a league source and via Adrian Wojnarowski, Anthony will be swiftly released by the Bulls, as he was last year by the Atlanta Hawks. Anthony won't play a game for the Bulls, league source tells ESPN. He will be released and become a free agent if he clears waivers. https://t.co/Oo2IA0nsJP — Adrian Wojnarowski (@wojespn) January 21, 2019 This officially gives Melo the opportunity to explore free agent opportunities. I pondered potential landing spots in November, and many of the teams remain hot destinations. The short-handed Los Angeles Lakers could be particularity interested as they search for depth amidst injuries. Header photo via ESPN More Sak Sports Patriots Quickly Lose Underdog Status in Fluctuating Vegas Line Follow Sak Sports Blog on Twitter ...